Fantastic Cat, often hailed as the Traveling Wilburys of smart indie pop, return with their sophomore album, Now That’s What I Call Fantastic Cat, building on the momentum of their acclaimed 2022 debut, The Very Best of Fantastic Cat. Comprised of Brian Dunne, Anthony D’Amato, Don DiLego, and Mike Montali, each member shares vocal duties, bringing a rich diversity to their sound. What began as a side project has blossomed into a full-fledged band with a distinctive blend of Americana, folk, and indie pop, all wrapped in a playful, yet sincere package.
The album opens with “Oh Man!”, an energetic track that sets the tone with its blend of ELO and Tom Petty influences, followed by “Little Bit Broken” and “Later On,” both showcasing the band’s knack for catchy melodies and tight harmonies. Their first single, “All My Fault,” evokes a “Me & Julio” vibe, highlighting the band’s ability to craft songs that are both nostalgic and fresh. The band’s humor and self-awareness shine through, particularly on tracks like “The Hammer & The Nail,” where witty lyrics are balanced with genuine relatability.
Despite their light-hearted approach, Fantastic Cat’s music is far from frivolous. “Sometimes Your Heroes Let You Down” offers a gospel-tinged, poignant reflection on disillusionment, while “Head Down, Shots Fired” channels a mix of The Eagles’ polished sound and the band’s own raw edge. The album’s production, handled by the band members themselves, is polished yet retains a sense of spontaneity and live energy, a testament to their collaborative chemistry and individual talents.
The band’s journey to this album was fraught with personal challenges, from heartbreak and legal troubles to sobriety and existential crises. This tumultuous backdrop only enriches the emotional depth of their music, making Now That’s What I Call Fantastic Cat not just a collection of songs, but a testament to resilience and artistic camaraderie. The eclectic instrumentation, including contributions from members of Counting Crows and other notable musicians, adds layers of texture and richness to the album.
In conclusion, Fantastic Cat’s second album is a triumphant follow-up that surpasses their debut in both scope and execution. It’s a record that blends humor with heartfelt storytelling, showcasing the band’s evolution while staying true to their roots. Whether you’re a fan of indie pop, Americana, or just great songwriting, this album is a must-listen, promising an engaging and memorable experience. – Jason Felton