When three lifelong indie-folk musicians—Eric D. Johnson of Fruit Bats, songwriter Anaïs Mitchell, and producer/session player Josh Kaufman—formed Bonny Light Horseman in 2018, they named their band and debut album after an ancient folk lament from the Napoleonic Wars. This deeply niche inspiration reflects the band’s dedication to historical and traditional music. Their second album moved towards original compositions but retained the historical essence. While this might not appeal to everyone, for fans like me, the challenge is for an hour-long, 20-song double album to truly deliver.
The band’s dedication to their craft is undeniable. Recorded in the centuries-old Levis Corner House pub in County Cork, Ireland, with session musicians, Keep Me on Your Mind / See You Free immerses listeners in its atmospheric setting. The opener, “Keep Me On Your Mind,” evokes the pub’s dark, weathered wood and the clink of pint glasses. The charming room noise on the 30-second interlude “think of the royalties, lads” enhances the album’s authenticity. Songs like “Hare and Hound” perfectly capture the timeless vibe the band treasures, blending modern and ancient influences.
The chemistry among Johnson, Mitchell, and Kaufman shines in the album’s quieter moments. “Into the O” relies on their three-part harmonies, showcasing their individual talents. Mitchell is celebrated for her work on Hadestown, Kaufman for his collaborations with artists like Taylor Swift and The National, and Johnson for his prolific output with Fruit Bats. Johnson’s vocals stand out in tracks like “Old Dutch” and “When I Was Younger,” demonstrating his growing confidence as a vocalist. Even in duets like “Lover Take It Easy,” Johnson’s jubilant voice often takes center stage.
Despite its traditional roots, Keep Me on Your Mind / See You Free might be the least traditional Bonny Light Horseman record. The album embraces full-throated folk rock, creating some of the best work the trio has produced. The band’s ability to merge historical and contemporary elements results in a record that feels both expansive and authentic, enhancing their unique appeal.
The 18-song double album is a reflection on longing, growing older, and pastoral life, filled with harmonies and melodies that linger. Recorded partly in the intimate setting of Levis Corner House, the album’s rich, atmospheric sound makes it a compelling listen. Bonny Light Horseman’s songs exist in their own time, brought to life by musicians with deep chemistry, making Keep Me on Your Mind / See You Free a truly generous gift. – Jason Felton